There is something profoundly paradoxical about the Bharatiya Janata Party launching a nationwide campaign under the slogan ‘Loktantra Bachao, Arajakta Hatao’ (Save Democracy, Remove Anarchy). A party that has been ruling the country at the Centre for more than 12 years, controls several state governments and enjoys considerable influence over the country’s political and administrative institutions has suddenly found itself campaigning to save democracy. The obvious question is: Who is threatening Indian democracy, and from whom does the ruling party need to save it?
The campaign, spearheaded by Union Home Minister Amit Shah and other senior BJP leaders, appears less an expression of concern for democracy and more an attempt to counter an increasingly damaging narrative being built by the Opposition over the credibility of India’s electoral process.
The timing is particularly significant. It follows the Congress-led INDIA bloc’s November 1 rally at Delhi’s Ramlila Maidan under the slogan ‘Vote Bachao, Desh Bachao’, where Opposition leaders questioned the Election Commission’s functioning, raised concerns over the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls and demanded accountability from CEC Gyanesh Kumar. The BJP responded with its own counter-campaign, taking the slogan of saving democracy to the streets.
The Ruling Party, Defender of Democracy against the Opposition?
The BJP’s counter-campaign raises a fundamental question about the responsibilities of a government in a parliamentary democracy. It is primarily the responsibility of the ruling establishment to protect democratic institutions, ensure the independence of constitutional authorities, uphold electoral fairness and guarantee citizens their fundamental rights. The Opposition, on the other hand, has the constitutional responsibility to question the government and hold it accountable.
But the BJP seems to have reversed these roles. Instead of addressing the specific allegations concerning the electoral process, it has chosen to portray the Opposition as an enemy of democracy and an agent of anarchy.
Politically Convenient but Democratically Questionable
The Opposition’s allegations are not confined to dissatisfaction with electoral defeats. They concern the manner in which electoral rolls are being revised, the deletion of voters’ names, the possibility of eligible citizens being deprived of their voting rights and the accountability of the Election Commission.
The reported deletion of a very large number of names during SIR has understandably raised apprehensions. The Opposition alleges that the exercise disproportionately affects vulnerable sections, including minorities, women and economically disadvantaged citizens. The Election Commission and the government maintain that the exercise is intended to eliminate duplicate, ineligible and otherwise invalid entries. But such an exercise must be transparent, verifiable and accompanied by effective safeguards against wrongful exclusion.
The government cannot dismiss these concerns merely by accusing those who raise them of spreading misinformation.
If the BJP is confident about the integrity of the electoral process, it should welcome an independent examination of the allegations. It should make the methodology, deletion figures, objections and restoration of names publicly accessible. A political procession cannot substitute for institutional transparency.
An Unusual Anxiety within the Ruling Establishment
The very necessity of this campaign reveals something about the BJP’s political calculations.For years, the party has enjoyed a formidable advantage in political communication. Its organisational machinery, extensive social media network and ability to dominate the public discourse have helped it shape political narratives. Yet the present situation suggests that the Opposition’s allegations about electoral irregularities have acquired sufficient public resonance to compel the ruling party to mount a coordinated counter-offensive.
The BJP apparently fears that the expression ‘vote chori’ may become a politically damaging public perception, particularly as the country approaches important electoral contests.
The BJP’s campaign is therefore not merely an exercise in defending the Election Commission. It is an attempt to prevent the Opposition from establishing a narrative that the institution responsible for conducting free and fair elections has lost public credibility.
There is an important distinction here. Defending an institution does not necessarily mean defending every decision taken by its functionaries. In fact, genuine respect for constitutional institutions requires that their functioning remain open to scrutiny.
The BJP’s approach seems to suggest that questioning the Election Commission amounts to undermining democracy. This is a dangerous proposition. In a democracy, constitutional authorities are not beyond criticism, and citizens do not surrender their right to question them simply because a political party happens to be in power.The government must answer questions with evidence, not counter-slogans.
Women in Burqa: A political Spectacle?
Perhaps the most striking feature of the Bhopal campaign was the presence of Muslim women wearing burqas, carrying BJP flags and displaying posters expressing gratitude to Prime Minister Narendra Modi, particularly for the abolition of instant triple talaq.
Their participation attracted considerable attention, with photographs and videos circulating widely on social media. Some posters reportedly carried messages such as ‘Modi Ji, will not go anywhere’, while others highlighted the government’s 2019 legislation criminalising instant triple talaq.
There is nothing objectionable about burqa-clad women participating in a political programme organised by the BJP. They are citizens of this country and have every right to support any political party of their choice. Nor should their political preferences be questioned merely because they belong to a minority community.
The question, however, is about the political significance attached to their presence and the manner in which it was showcased.Why has the BJP suddenly become so eager to demonstrate Muslim women’s support for its political agenda? Is it an expression of genuine concern for their welfare, or an attempt to counter the widespread perception that the party’s politics has alienated the Muslim community? It is also alleged that non-Muslim women were under burqa.
The Distinction is Important
The BJP has consistently sought to project its triple talaq legislation as evidence of its commitment to Muslim women’s emancipation. But its passage cannot by itself establish that Muslim women have embraced the BJP’s wider political and ideological agenda.
Muslim women’s empowerment is a much larger issue. It encompasses education, employment, economic independence, equal opportunities, personal security, protection against discrimination and freedom from social and political marginalisation.
What about the insecurity experienced by Muslim women when their families and communities face communal violence, their localities bulldozed and shelters are razed to ground? What about the discrimination reported in housing, employment and educational institutions? What about the political rhetoric that routinely portrays Muslims as outsiders or demographic threats?
A government genuinely interested in winning the confidence of Muslim women must address these questions as seriously as it celebrates the triple talaq legislation.A handful of women carrying party flags cannot be treated as a referendum on the sentiments of an entire community.
There is also an important factual distinction. Reports from Bhopal establish the participation of burqa-clad women in the BJP’s main rally and their display of party slogans and posters. They do not, by themselves, establish that an independent Muslim women’s rally was organised. The political spectacle, however, was clearly used to project an image of minority support.
The Contradiction the BJP Cannot Wish Away
The BJP’s effort to display Muslim women’s support also exposes a contradiction in its political approach.On the one hand, the party seeks to demonstrate that Muslims, particularly Muslim women, are comfortable with its politics. On the other, its political discourse frequently relies on polarising rhetoric, suspicion and the construction of Muslims as a distinct ‘political problem’.
The party cannot have it both ways indefinitely. It cannot expect the Muslim community to applaud its selective welfare measures while remaining silent about the larger atmosphere of apprehension and alienation.
If the BJP genuinely wants to reach out to Muslim women, it must demonstrate that commitment through policies and conduct rather than carefully choreographed political appearances.
Democracy Needs Answers, Not Competing Slogans
The Bhopal padyatra, led by BJP president J.P. Nadda and Madhya Pradesh Chief Minister Mohan Yadav, was part of the party’s wider counter-campaign. The BJP claimed that around one lakh people would participate, while reports citing traffic police estimates put the actual turnout at approx. 40,000 to 50,000. But the size of a procession does not establish the truth of its political message.
Democracy is not protected by the number of people marching behind party flags. It is protected by the credibility of elections, the independence of constitutional institutions, the freedom of the media, the protection of minorities and the government’s willingness to answer uncomfortable questions.
If the BJP believes that the Opposition is misleading the people, it should expose the alleged falsehoods through verifiable facts. If the Election Commission has conducted SIR fairly, it should demonstrate this through transparent procedures and independently verifiable data.
And if the BJP genuinely wants the confidence of Muslim women, it must offer them more than a photograph with party flags.
The greatest irony of the ‘Save Democracy’ campaign is that the party in power appears more preoccupied with saving its political narrative than addressing the questions being raised about the health of Indian democracy. A government confident of its democratic credentials does not need to turn every criticism into an act of alleged subversion. It needs to demonstrate, through its actions, that democracy is safe in its hands.
Until then, the question will remain: Is the BJP really trying to save democracy, or is it trying to save itself from the growing political consequences of questions being asked in its name?


