DR. RAZIUL ISLAM NADVI, Asst. Editor of Urdu research quarterly, Tahqeeqat-e-Islami, is a great Islamic scholar and author of many books on the various aspects of Islam and Islamic Shari’ah. In an interview with WAQUAR HASAN, he throws light on the different facets of Islamic Shari’ah. Excerpts:
What is the history of Fatwa? Was it present during the time of Prophet Muhammad (peace and blessings of Allah be to him)?
Fatwa means to explain guidance of Islam. The guidance may be present with explanation in the Qur’ān and Hadith or one has to exert guidance in new matters in the light of the Holy Qur’ān and Hadith. During the time of Prophet Muhammad (peace and blessings of Allah be to him), he himself was the first Mufti. Generally, the fatwa of the Blessed Prophet was on the basis of wahi (revelation). Sometime he used to give fatwa by exertion of wahi (revelation). There are a lot of stories reported in books of Hadith in which the Blessed Prophet answered the questions of his companion with exertion.
Besides, a lot of companions of the Prophet gave fatwa with permission of the Prophet during his lifetime. The Prophet sent Maaz bin Jabal to Yemen with the permission of it. Besides Caliphs Abu Bakr, Umar, Usman and Ali – Obei bin Kaab, Zaid bin Haris and Abdur Rahman bin Ouf also used to issue fatwa during the lifetime of the Blessed Prophet.
What is the validity and legality of fatwa in Islam?
The role of fatwa is supposed to be information. One approaches the Mufti to seek guidance of Shari’ah in a certain matter? The Mufti explains to him the guidance. He himself does not make any action mandatory and he does not force the seeker to implement it. It is on his choice whether he accepts it or seeks the advice of another Mufit if he is not satisfied.
What is impact of fatwa on the Muslim society?
It is necessary for a Mufti that he has very deep insight in the basic sources of Islam. He must have power of exertion in new matters in the light of sources. He must have deep knowledge of interpretations, theories and principles and be aware of the spirit of Shari’ah. Generally, such types of persons issue fatwa. So, it is viewed as valued and glorified in the Muslim society. People present their new matters to Mufti, and try to implement the Fatwa.
Is fatwa part of Shari’ah?
There are some matters in human life, whose guidance is present in the Holy Qur’ān and Sunnah with explanation and there are also some new matters whose guidance is observed in the light of the Qur’ān and Sunnah by exertion (ijtehad) and supposition (qiyas). Fatwa is the name of explaining this guidance. According to this, Fatwa is the part of Shari’ah. But the status of fatwa is that of an opinion. There may be difference between the opinions of different persons. Therefore, in changing scenario of the present time, the collective exertion (ijtehad) in the Qur’ān and Sunnah has been promoted to resolve new matters. And this endeavour is going on in different countries, including India.
How do you view the comment of the Supreme Court on fatwa?
A PIL was lodged that Shari’ah court should be banned and illegalised. But the court rejected the petition and said that if Shari’ah court is not legal, how it can be illegalised? We welcome this verdict of the Supreme Court. And this ruling of the Supreme Court is also correct that Shari’ah courts neither seize the individual rights of a citizen nor one is bound to implement its verdict. The verdict removes a lot of misunderstandings and doubts about Fatwa and Shari’ah courts.


