The BJP-led Maharashtra government’s decision to move towards a Uniform Civil Code (UCC) is a textbook case study of misplaced priorities and communal politics. The move also throws up a fundamental question: does equality necessarily mandate uniformity? Muslim organisations led by the All India Muslim Personal Law Board (AIMPLB) and the Federation of Maharashtra Muslims (FMM) say that it doesn’t.
On July 9, 2026, the Maharashtra government constituted a 7-member committee headed by retired Supreme Court Judge Justice Ranjana Desai to examine and prepare a framework for a UCC. The committee has been tasked with examining personal laws relating to marriage, divorce, inheritance and succession. It has invited public responses through a multilingual consultation portal and plans to visit six administrative divisions.
The government is reportedly planning to introduce the UCC bill during the winter session in Nagpur. The government has no other explanation for the proposed UCC other than the fact that it is part of the Directive Principles of State Policy under Article 44 of the Constitution.
Article 44 is Not a Blank Cheque
It is undeniable that Article 44 directs the State to endeavour to secure a uniform civil code for citizens throughout the territory of India. But the provision is part of the Directive Principles and not an independently enforceable Fundamental Right. Article 37 of the Constitution of India makes it clear that these principles are fundamental to governance but are not enforceable by any court. The expression under Article 44 ‘shall endeavour’ does not prescribe a deadline nor does it amount to an unconditional command to impose a uniform civil code immediately. Article 44 has to be read alongside the Constitution’s enforceable guarantees, particularly Articles 14, 15, 19, 21, 25, 26 and 29. A Directive Principle is not a licence to bypass fundamental rights. Yes, the State has a responsibility to pursue equality and social justice. However, the methodology should be consistent with constitutional guarantees.
Also, there is the erroneous assumption that equality and uniformity are interchangeable. Part of government propaganda is that religious communities enjoying different legal treatment (by having the freedom to practise their personal laws) amounts to appeasement and discrimination for the rest. A narrative is being spread that imposing an identical civil code across communities is the only conceivable way to justice.
Religious Freedom and Personal Law
For Muslims, personal law is not simply a collection of administrative rules governing private relationships. Marriage, divorce, inheritance and succession have a direct connection with their religious beliefs and obligations.
One must understand that Article 25 also protects freedom of conscience. If a citizen’ conscience is reconciled to a particular way of life, no law can snatch that freedom. Again, under Article 21, privacy, dignity and personal autonomy are intrinsic to family matters. If the government feels that certain religious practices must undergo reform then it is possible only through meaningful engagement with affected communities. Reform cannot be imposed from outside, it has to be organic and from within the community.
The Unresolved Question of Necessity
The 21st Law Commission’s Consultation Paper on Reform of Family Law, dated August 31, 2018, concluded that a UCC was ‘neither necessary nor desirable’ at that stage. Muslims argue that the Maharashtra government must identify the specific developments or deficiencies that justify the imposition of UCC. The committee is therefore obliged to establish the problem before prescribing a uniform solution. But will it do so?
If the concern is gender injustice, the government should identify the discriminatory provisions and explain how they will be addressed. If the concern is legal complexity, it should demonstrate how uniformity would resolve it. If the government is concerned about women’s rights, surely imposing a single uniform code is not the appropriate instrument. The government should instead focus on economic dependence, social discrimination and unequal access to justice for the women of Maharashtra.
Consultation Must Be Genuine
The government has a propensity of creating bogus stakeholders and placing them in parallel with the real people being affected by new legislation. This trickery has now been perfected after rigorous application during the introduction of triple talaq and waqf laws. These dummy stakeholders toe the government line and allow the government to amplify its narrative and project that its proposed legislation is the voice of the people. This surreptitious method allows the government to evade inclusive and transparent consultation involving the core leadership of religious communities, legal scholars, lawyers, and civil society.
Unless the government pursues genuine consultation, there will always remain a trust deficit and the entire exercise will be seen as a sham and fraud perpetuated in the name of ‘stakeholder management’. Democratic legitimacy cannot be claimed by floating an online questionnaire for a few months.
Communities whose religious and family practices may be affected must have a meaningful opportunity to understand, debate and respond to the proposals. Those who drafted theConstitution did not envision that every community must become identical in order for citizens to enjoy equal rights. Treating uniformity as an unquestionable national objective is a patent falsehood that needs to be challenged legally. The case for imposing a Uniform Civil Code therefore remains fraught with the danger of trampling on the fundamental rights of citizens without any tangible outcome.
Maharashtra Muslims Respond
The Maharashtra government has formed a committee to examine the possible implementation of the UCC in the state, following similar moves by other states. The government has launched an online portal and invited public responses to 37 questions. Recognising that many people lack familiarity with the portal and the appropriate answers, the AIMPLB, in consultation with its legal team and in coordination with the FMM, decided to release a QR code to assist respondents. The QR code also includes a direct link to the government portal for easy access. Sunni Jamiat Ulama and Raza Academy are also running a signature campaign to raise awareness against the UCC.
Meanwhile, the Association for Protection of Civil Rights (APCR) has approached the Supreme Court of India challenging the constitutional validity of the proposed UCC which is officially called the Maharashtra Freedom of Religion Act, 2026, raising concerns over its implications for freedom of conscience, religious liberty, personal autonomy and privacy. The PIL, titled Association for Protection of Civil Rights (APCR) v. State of Maharashtra, was filed on October 14 through Shakir Sheikh, Secretary of APCR Maharashtra.
UCC is nothing but a distraction and Aldous Huxley correctly stated, “Non-stop distractions of the most fascinating nature… are deliberately used as instruments of policy, for the purpose of preventing people from paying too much attention to the realities of the social and political situation.”


