Mahmood Ghaznawi A Victim of Bias

In the medieval history of India three Muslim rulers – Aurangzeb Alamgir, one of the descendants of Mughal dynasty; Tipu Sultan, an able son of Haider Ali, ruler of Mysore; and Sultan Mahmood of Ghazni

Written by

M.S. QAIS

Published on

In the medieval history of India three Muslim rulers – Aurangzeb Alamgir, one of the descendants of Mughal dynasty; Tipu Sultan, an able son of Haider Ali, ruler of Mysore; and Sultan Mahmood of Ghazni, a small state in the Asian part of Russian Turkistan – have got prominent places not for their able and just administration but for certain ignoble acts they are alleged to have undertaken during their respective reigns.

They are remembered with the highest degree of vehemence and bias and are associated with certain acts which, in fact, none of them even think of doing, not to say of actually undertaking the same. The most hurting and blood-curdling allegations made against all the afore-mentioned three emperors revolve round destruction of temples, looting of valuables and conversion of non-Muslim subjects to Islam by force.

However, it is not surprising at all that such baseless and fabricated allegations have had originated in the satanic brains of some English historians, whose main objective behind doing this had been to divide the Indian society into two main camps – Hindu and Muslim. And, in order to incite the feelings and sentiments of the Hindu brethren against Muslims, the English played their nefarious games very intelligently and tactfully. And, they were successful in accomplishing their ends revolving around ‘divide and rule’ to a great extent.

However, barring a few, most of our Indian historians, writers and columnists have had based their narratives and descriptions upon what the English writers chose to say about the said emperors to suit their purposes. Amazing as it may appear, for such an ignominious act, English historians are treated with much reverence and trust. We Indians, especially the anti-Muslim elements, are indebted to such English historians and writers for their bringing to the fore the fabricated and baseless accounts in connection with the above mentioned much maligned Muslim rulers, in particular.

However, a true picture of Aurangzeb, one of the Mughal emperors and, probably, the most maligned one, has been presented by Dr. S. Ausaf Saied Vasfi in his article, “Much Maligned Aurangzeb Alamgir” (Radiance Viewsweekly, 20-26 September, 2015). And, on Tipu Sultan’s administration, based on the true spirit of secularism, his relations with the Hindu subjects, this scribe could gather certain necessary facts and figures from a thin book entitled Tipu Shaheed ki Aakhri Aaram Gah per written in Urdu by Shamim Tarique and published by Iqra Education Society, Jalgaon.  This article, “Shaheed Tipu – Through the Mirror of Truth”, based on the facts and figures available in the said book, was also published in this weekly (29 Nov. – 4 Dec. 2015).

Undoubtedly, the English, who ruled over India for a pretty long time, gave us certain good things, among which railways and banking system are most prominent. It is but an irony that they, simultaneously, sowed the seed of animosity in the hearts and minds of the common mass of undivided India. The seed, with the passage of time, bloomed well and grew strong. However, the rift between the two major communities, i.e. Hindu and Muslim, was widened and solidified enough by framing and placing forth certain baseless and instigating allegations encompassing the administration of some Muslim rulers in India.

The character assassination and representation of the Muslim rulers with bias, prejudice and narrow-mindedness has, in fact, played a pivotal role in erecting a wall of animosity between the members belonging to Hindu and Muslim communities. If such narratives are measured with the yardstick of justice and conscience, the foul game played by the biased writers becomes clear. Such narratives are applauded and embraced only by those whose minds are infested with the germs of hatred, prejudice and ill-conceived ideas towards the Muslim community and Islam as a whole. Most of such works are produced and manufactured in the factories where machines are operated but by communal minded persons. These biased and narrow-minded persons have ever been engaged in audaciously perverting the facts and truths and thereby undermining the true spirit of secularism in a country where pluralism and diversity are the chief characteristics of the nation.

To win the confidence of the majority community, English historians did whatever was possible by placing the distorted and mutilated pictures of the Muslim rulers. In the absence of any authentic accounts, which could reflect the Muslim rulers in their true colour, it proved to be a golden opportunity for biased and prejudiced English historians and writers to play their ugly games of “divide and rule” freely.  In their mission they were successful to a great extent. We Indians, especially a major segment of the majority community, give much importance to what English historians have said. It is all the more lamentable that most of the Indian writers rely and base their accounts upon what the English writers said and wrote.

Regarding Mahmood Ghaznawi, Auriya Maqbool Jan has written an excellent piece of a short narrative which is based on a chapter captioned “Somnath – the Many Voices of History”. This chapter is fully discussed and highlighted upon in a book entitled A History of India, by Romila Thapar, published by Penguin. The narrative of A.M. Jan is entitled “Mahmood Ghaznawi: Somnath aur Angrezoo’n ki Bad-Deyanati” (Mahmood Ghaznawi: Somnath and Unscrupulousness of the English).  Rasheed Afroz, Assistant Editor of a widely read bi-monthly Urdu magazine Gulbun published from Lucknow, has got A.M. Jan’s narrative about Mahmood Ghaznawi published under his usual caption ‘Arzang’ in the said bi-monthly (November-December, 2015).

Romila Thapar made a deep and thorough research, going through the historical facts and accounts available in Sanskrit and Persian. But, she could not trace out any evidence reflecting Mahmood Ghaznawi’s alleged criminal acts relating to the destruction of Somnath Temple, plundering and looting the valuables collected in the temple premises and taking the same away to Ghazni. Thapar very specifically says that all such allegations are totally fabricated and baseless. It is nothing but a shameful act of the English historians. The destruction of the ‘big idol’ of Somnath alleged to have been done by Mahmood is a mere rumour and well-oiled propaganda that the enemies of this Muslim ruler meticulously galvanised into belief of the members belonging to the majority community.

During the reign of the English, Mahmood was served with the ugly title of ‘Buut Shikan’ (Persian term, which means ‘Idol Breaker’). Unfortunately, some members of the Muslim community were also made to believe that Mahmood indeed broke up the big idol.  And, as such, they thought it not wrong to call him ‘Buut Shikan’ (idol breaker).
There is another charge brought against this Muslim ruler. This relates to the ‘Sandal-wood-doors’ of Somnath Temple, which are alleged to have been taken away to Ghazni by Mahmood. This mischievous notion originated in the deliberations held in the British Parliament in 1843 about how to get back the said doors from Ghazni to India. And, as such, the deliberation held in 1843 is remembered as the ‘action plan for doors retrieval’. The then Governor General, Lord Ellon Borough’s declaration that the doors were actually the national asset of India, and the same must be brought back to restore the prestige and dignity of the country, was given much importance.

The most important aspect of this episode is the truth that in the documents both in the Sanskrit and Persian scripts, there is no mention at all of such happenings concerning the looting of the ‘sandal-wood-doors’. Romila Thapar speaks of this specifically in her aforementioned book.

However, the main objective of the English behind playing this ugly game and maligning the Muslim ruler was to associate the Hindus with the war that was planned to be waged in Afghanistan as well as to prove as to how much the English had been successful in bringing the country (Afghanistan) under their subjugation. Ultimately, with the help of local Hindu soldiers, an attack was launched against Afghanistan. This attack paved the way for bringing the alleged doors back to India.

Now mind how the reality emerged from behind the curtain. When the doors were looked at, verses of the holy Qur’ān were found inscribed on the body of the wooden-doors. Obviously, this brought the truth above the board that Mahmood Ghaznawi did not have any connection with the doors of Somnath temple. It is but a tragedy that the said doors were in no way utilised and have been getting rotten in the store room of the Agra Fort.

Thapar further says in her book that she minutely went through some historical descriptions in Sanskrit wherein she did find the name of a town called Somnath, but she did not find any mention of any big temple. She further states that before the arrival of Mahmood Ghaznawi to India, the town of Somnath was invaded by the Jains (followers of the faith called ‘Jainism’). They are claimed to have destroyed one temple there (Somnath) and regarded this act as a victory of Lord Mahavir (founder of Jainism) over Shiva (one of the Hindu gods).

Thapar goes on stating that she got this information after going through the source material on the Jain faith. She then states with much surprise and concern that she tried to get some evidence in the history of Jainism and in the literature and historical accounts available in Sanskrit to ascertain whether or not Mahmood Ghaznawi actually destroyed any temple and looted the same, but she failed in getting any trace of such evidence at all.

If probed thoroughly and conscientiously, it would be quite clear that the Jains and the historical source material in Sanskrit give least regard and importance to Sultan Mahmood’s arrival to India as well as the battle that he fought on the soil here. These two happenings (Mahmood’s arrival to India and the battle he fought here) are assumed and considered to be quite small and insignificant.

On the other hand, the authors of the Jain faith and Sanskrit speak elaborately of the decoration and embellishment of the temple and also the construction of a mosque. Thapar further says that the town of Somnath was inhabited by both the Hindus and the Muslim traders. These Muslim traders were allotted a plot of land for the construction of a mosque. The writer then mentions of an epitaph, the inscription of which speaks of a Muslim who got the noble place of martyrdom in a battle while defending the town of Somnath against the invaders.

Now let us turn our attention to the time when the fabricated, perverted and distorted historical and socio-political accounts depicting India were forcefully brought before both the native people and aliens. And, this also affected the said Muslim ruler. In the year 1872, two authors, H.M Elliot and Ed. John Dowson, with the patronage of the English rulers, compiled a history book entitled History of India – As told by its own historians. The main objective behind bringing out this book was to project that India ‘is a divided country’, the people here are always at ‘daggers drawn’ relationship with one another, they ‘can’t defend themselves against the attackers’, Muslim invaders are ‘brutal’, people are too ‘zealots and very harsh’ religiously, and it is only the English who ‘can bring about complete peace and stability in the country’.

It is quite pathetic that the above accounts were specifically mentioned in the history textbooks prescribed in the syllabus for the students in India and Pakistan and for a pretty long time it was being taught to students. It also served as a palatable masalah for the people indulged in gossip. Through their misleading and fabricated accounts, the said two authors succeeded in accomplishing their cherished objective of convincing the people that Mahmood Ghaznawi was a ‘lootera’, Aurangzeb was ‘cruel’, Muslims were inhuman in their behaviour with the Hindus and destroyers of temples, Anar Kali was a real, not fictitious, character, etc. etc.

But, as Romila Thapar further states, no history book in the country backs and supports the claims highlighting the destruction, looting and plundering of the temples by the Muslim rulers. Instead, the Indian history connects such barbaric acts with the native kings and monarchs who had been perpetrating such criminal acts for centuries. Thapar further says that the Epigraphic Account of the kings of Chhola and Chalooka dynasties, who ruled over different parts of the subcontinent, tells that they would attack, loot and destroy the temples to maintain their might and superiority.
In 642 C.E. the Pallava king, Narasimhavarman-I conquered Wapiti, the capital of Chalukya kingdom and after destroying the Ganesh temple he took away the Ganesh idol with him. Then, half a century later, Chalukya king, Datiya conquered different areas and brought the Ganesh idol back. After destroying different temples, he brought the Ganga and Jamuna idols to Deccan also. Similar destruction was caused to temples by the Rashtrakota’s king Gonda, who conquered Kanjipur in the 9th century C.E. The said king also plundered all the idols installed in the temples in Sri Lanka and decorated the Shiv Temple in India with the same. Bodh places of worship in Ajanta and Ellora were completely destroyed and after installing the idols of Shiv and Ganga there, it was converted into a ‘temple’.

Nobody is quite sure if Alexander the Great was the first to initiate the destruction of the places of worship of others by razing Iran’s Persi-Police to the ground. Similar facts, figures and accounts surround the Somnath. And, this remains hidden because of the unscrupulousness of the English historians. Sultan Mahmood Ghaznawi did nothing of the kind as projected deceitfully by the biased, prejudiced and dishonest English writers.

Quite amazing and interesting as it may appear, some of the English historians say that the world’s greatest library situated at Alexandria was destroyed during the Caliphate of the Second Caliph Umar; whereas the fact remains that the said library was burnt to ashes in 600 B.C on the instruction of a Roman king. The English authors made this falsehood an important part of history. And, as such, repeatedly stated lie assumed the status of a fact, as is the story mirroring Mahmood Ghaznawi.