Muslim Reformers and the Evolution of Women’s Roles in India Struggle, Determination, and Perseverance

It was within the intellectual environment of the Aligarh Movement that discussions surrounding women’s education began to take shape. Reformers and thinkers engaged in intense debates, presenting diverse, and often contradictory, arguments regarding the necessity, limits, and nature of female education. The early activists, scholars, thinkers, and writers who worked for Muslim women’s reforms were…

Written by

ZeenatPerween Bint Badr

Published on

When did the Indian woman first step beyond the boundaries of the private sphere and into the world of education, intellectual patronage, and public service?The answer is neither recent nor accidental; it is rooted in centuries of reform, courage, and vision. The making of modern India cannot be understood without acknowledging the gradual but decisive transformation of women’s roles in education, patronage, and community life, a transformation nurtured by visionary Muslim reformers, patrons, and institution-builders across centuries.

Their contributions were shaped by an engagement with the Qur’anic message, which emphasises equity, compassion, and the inherent worth of women. Rather than viewing reform as a departure from tradition, they understood it as a return to foundational principles – an effort to embody divine guidance within evolving social realities.

To better understand how Muslims contributed to the reconfiguration of women’s roles in India, it is helpful to revisit the efforts of key reformers whose work shaped educational and social transformation across different historical moments.

 

Maulana Abul Kalam Azad (1888–1958)

Born in 1888 in Makkah and brought up in Calcutta (now Kolkata), Abul Kalam Azad evolved from a young journalist into one of India’s foremost national leaders, guided by a deep engagement with reformist thought and educational renewal. Decades later, his ideas remain central to debates surrounding inclusive and accessible education in India.

Gandhiji referred to Maulana Azad as “Emperor of Learning”. Maulana Azad strongly emphasised the importance of education at all times. He considered education to be the fundamental pillar in nation-building. He played a pivotal role in the establishment of several renowned educational institutions, viz., the first-ever Indian Institute of Technology (IIT) in 1951, the University Grants Commission (UGC) in 1953, and the Central Institute of Education, Delhi (now the Department of Education of Delhi University).

He also emphasised the development of the Indian Institute of Science, Bangalore, and the Faculty of Technology of Delhi University. In January 1947, Maulana Azad joined the Interim Government when Mr. Asaf Ali was appointed India’s Ambassador in Washington. In 1952, he was given additional charge of the portfolio of Natural Resources and Scientific Research. He started the Indian Council for Cultural Relations: an organisation to establish and strengthen cultural contacts between India and other countries of the East. In 1992, he was posthumously honoured with India’s highest Civilian award, Bharat Ratna, owing to his key role in promoting primary and secondary education, scientific education, and the establishment of IITs, IIMs, and UGC. His immense contribution to the field of education in India is recognised by celebrating his birthday as National Education Day.

Maulana Azad firmly believed that “No programme of national education can be appropriate if it does not give full consideration to the education and advancement of one-half of society – the women.” This statement, made in the Constituent Assembly, underscores his conviction that women’s education was not just beneficial but essential to the nation’s progress.

Maulana Azad envisioned education as a transformative force that transcended barriers of caste, religion, and gender. His contributions were not merely policy-oriented but philosophically rooted in inclusivity, equity, and empowerment. Azad’s establishment of institutions like the IITs and the UGC exemplified his commitment to fostering excellence and accessibility in education. Despite these foundations, contemporary India faces significant challenges in fulfilling its vision. Millions of children remain out of school, particularly from marginalised communities, while issues like the digital divide, teacher shortages, and inadequate mental health support further exacerbate disparities. This chapter revisits Azad’s legacy, critically examines gaps in India’s education system, and offers actionable solutions aligned with his ideals. Strengthening foundational learning, bridging the digital divide, addressing systemic inequities, and prioritising mental health are essential to realising Azad’s dream of an inclusive, equitable education system. As India grapples with modern educational challenges, Azad’s vision serves as both a guide and a reminder of the transformative power of education in shaping a just and harmonious society.

Azad believed education was a universal right; by institutionalising mass and inclusive education, he opened intellectual and social space for women’s participation in nation-building. His vision extended beyond national boundaries, reflecting an internationalist outlook that imagined universities as spaces for intellectual exchange and cooperation, contributing ultimately towards a more just and harmonious world order.

While Maulana Azad carried forward the dream of inclusive and modern education in independent India, the roots of this transformation can be traced back to the reformist vision of Sir Syed Ahmed Khan, who initiated a profound intellectual awakening in the 19th century.

 

Sir Syed Ahmed Khan (1817-1898)

Sir Syed Ahmed Khan was a multifaceted personality. He was a modernist thinker, a daring theologian, an educationist, a journalist, and a prolific writer. In addition, he earned fame for establishing the Mohammadian Anglo-Oriental College, which later became Aligarh Muslim University (AMU).

Sir Syed’s intellectual character was profoundly shaped by the influence of his mother, Aziz-un-Nisa Begum. In his work Seerat-e-Fardiya, he speaks with deep admiration of her education, her proficiency in Persian literature, and her strong grounding in Islamic scholarship. He acknowledges her as a central figure in nurturing his intellectual curiosity and moral development.

Mohammedan Anglo-Oriental (MAO) College aimed to provide modern education while preserving cultural heritage.

The Aligarh Institute Gazette, initiated by him, campaigned against practices such as female infanticide, polygamy, child marriage, sati, segregation of widows, and poverty-induced marriages of young girls to older men.His progressive social ideas were disseminated through his magazine, Tahdhib-ul-Akhlaq.

The question of women’s education in the Indian subcontinent emerged within a complex landscape of intellectual debate, social reform, and cultural resistance during the 19th century. While modern education for boys gradually gained acceptance among reformers after the events of 1857, the idea of educating girls through modern institutions remained deeply contested and, for many, almost unimaginable.

It was within the intellectual environment of the Aligarh Movement that discussions surrounding women’s education began to take shape. Reformers and thinkers engaged in intense debates, presenting diverse, and often contradictory, arguments regarding the necessity, limits, and nature of female education. The early activists, scholars, thinkers, and writers who worked for Muslim women’s reforms were those who were directly or indirectly influenced by Sir Syed Ahmad Khan.

Among the earliest writings, we have novels of Nazir Ahmad Dehlvi (Mirat-ul-Uroos, The Bride’s Mirror) and Maulana Altaf Hussain Hali (Majalis-un-Nisa, Conversations Among Women). These two novels stood for women’s education in becoming good husbands, wives, housemakers, and moral guides to children. After this, Mohammadi Begum, the second wife of Sayyid Mumtaz Ali, wrote the novel Shareef Beti (The Noble Daughter) that championed women’s education.

The reformist vision of Sir Syed Ahmad Khan did not emerge in an atmosphere of applause but amid suspicion, ridicule, and theological resistance. Fatwas were issued, journals launched against him, and satire turned him into a public spectacle. Yet it was precisely within this climate of opposition that the foundations of modern educational reform, including the later transformation of women’s roles, were quietly laid.

If Sir Syed’s contribution lay in reshaping intellectual attitudes toward modern education, the next challenge was to translate this awakening into tangible opportunities, particularly in the sphere of women’s education. This task was taken forward by Syed Karamat Hussain, who transformed reformist ideals into institutional reality. At a time when educating women still faced social hesitation, he expanded the reformist vision beyond discourse by establishing educational initiatives that opened new pathways for women’s learning in the United Provinces.

 

Justice Maulvi Syed Karamat Hussain (1854-1917)

There are individuals whose quiet resolve reshapes the destiny of generations. Justice Syed Karamat Husain, a distinguished jurist and a committed advocate of women’s education, was one such figure whose enduring legacy continues to inspire and empower society. Living much of his life away from public acclaim, he devoted his intellect and authority to a cause that few men of his time were prepared to champion: the education of women.

At a time when female education was met with hesitation and often outright resistance, Karamat Husain regarded it not merely as a social reform but as a moral imperative. He firmly believed that the progress of any society was inseparable from the intellectual and moral advancement of its women. From an early stage, his forward-looking vision recognised that no community could secure its future without educating its daughters.

This conviction translated into meaningful action. His persistent efforts contributed to the establishment of major educational initiatives for women in the United Provinces: in Allahabad (1895), Aligarh (1906), and Lucknow (1912). The institution founded in Lucknow, later named after him, stands as a lasting testament to his dedication to education and social reform. Today, Karamat Husain Muslim Girls’ P.G. College, Lucknow, remains a living tribute to his pioneering role in expanding educational opportunities for women.

The institutions founded by Syed Karamat Hussain demonstrated that women’s education was both possible and necessary. Building upon this momentum, Sheikh Abdullah advanced the movement further by working to normalise girls’ education within society and by creating spaces where families increasingly felt confident sending their daughters to study.

 

Sheikh Abdullah (Papa Mian, 1874-1965)

Sheikh Abdullah was a pioneering Indian reformer who revolutionised Muslim women’s education by establishing the Aligarh Girls’ School (1906), which developed into the Women’s College at Aligarh Muslim University (AMU). He championed women’s rights, fighting social oppression through initiatives like the journal Khatoon and by promoting education to liberate women.

In 1935, British India awarded him the honorary title of Khan Bahadur. After completing his education at Aligarh Muslim University, the university awarded him a Doctor of Law, an honorary degree, in 1950. In 1964, 18 years after Partition, the Government of India awarded him Padma Bhushan, the third-highest Indian civilian award, in recognition of his contribution to female education. The university’s women’s college, Abdullah College, is named after him.

As we discuss the architects of women’s social and intellectual transformation, one cannot overlook Rashid-ul-Khairi, rightly remembered as Musavvir-e-Niswan (the Painter of Women), whose pen reshaped societal perceptions as powerfully as institutions reshaped access to education.

 

Rashid ul Khairi (1868-1936)

The reform movements of the 19th century were largely initiated by an educated Muslim elite that possessed both intellectual awareness and effective means of communication. Among Indian Muslims, the late 19th century witnessed the emergence of a powerful concern for the reform of women’s condition, a concern that, in practice, translated primarily into a movement for women’s education and moral uplift. Reformers envisioned the creation of women who would become better wives, responsible mothers, and morally conscious members of society. This objective generated extensive discussions and debates on the women’s question, both in public forums and within the rapidly expanding world of print culture. By the 1870s, Urdu print culture had begun to actively engage with issues relating to women through novels, biographical writings, advice manuals, and literature addressing household management, child-rearing, and health. Although reformers shared a common goal, their motivations and approaches varied, leading each to emphasise different dimensions of reform in their writings.

It was within this vibrant intellectual and literary environment that Rashid-ul-Khairi emerged as one of the most influential voices of social reform. A prominent reformer of British India and a distinguished contributor to Urdu literature, Khairi blended reformist and didactic teachings with literary creativity, becoming one of the pioneers of the Urdu short story. Through emotionally compelling narratives, he transformed reformist ideas into accessible moral discourse, bringing debates on women’s education and social reform from elite intellectual circles into the everyday moral imagination of Muslim households.

His commitment to women’s uplift found concrete expression in June 1908 with the founding of Ismat, a social and literary magazine dedicated to women, which actively promoted female education and advocated awareness of women’s legal and social rights. A remarkably prolific author, Khairi produced more than 90 books and booklets, including SathRuhoonkeAamalnamay and Nani Ashu, works that combined literary appeal with social critique and vividly portrayed the lived realities of women in the Indian subcontinent. His literary legacy also continued through his family, as he was the father of Urdu novelist Sadiq ul Khairi and the grandfather of noted jurist HaziqulKhairi.

Khairi’s contribution received wide recognition from contemporaries and later scholars alike. Munshi Premchand acknowledged him as a towering figure in women’s Urdu literature. At the same time, historian Gail Minault described him as a pioneer of women’s rights within the Islamic intellectual tradition who sought to challenge the physical and psychological confinement of women. Celebrated novelist QurratulainHyder similarly regarded him as one of the greatest reformers of the 20th century, underscoring the enduring impact of his efforts to reshape social consciousness through literature.

As reformist discussions in colonial India began to shift from merely educating women to redefining their place within society, the conversation entered a new and more challenging phase. In this charged intellectual atmosphere, Sayyid Mumtaz Ali appeared as one of the few thinkers willing to question inherited assumptions and advocate a thoughtful re-evaluation of women’s rights and social position.

 

Sayyid Mumtaz Ali Deobandi (1860-1935)

Sayyid Mumtaz Ali was an Indian Muslim scholar and an advocate of women’s rights in the late 19th century. He was an alumnus of DarulUloom Deoband. His book Huquq-e-Niswan and the journal Tehzeeb-e-Niswan, which he started with his wife, Muhammadi Begum, are said to be pioneering works on women’s rights.

American historian Gail Minault observes in her study on Sayyid Mumtaz Ali that his work Huquq-un-Niswan was far ahead of its time, representing one of the earliest and most thoughtful attempts to advocate women’s rights within the framework of Islamic law. In the context of continuing debates on Muslim personal reform, she regards Mumtaz Ali as an important early voice who sought to reinterpret social practices in light of justice and ethical responsibility.

His scholarly contributions were not limited to social reform alone. His Qur’anic exegesis Tafsil al-Bayan fīMaqasid al-Qur’an, a six-volume work, received remarkable recognition from leading scholars of the Muslim world. The former Grand Mufti of Jerusalem, Amin al-Husseini, is reported to have praised it as a work whose like was rarely found even in the Arab scholarly tradition. The work was also appreciated by prominent intellectual figures such as Anwar Shah Kashmiri, Abul Kalam Azad, and Syed SulaimanNadwi, reflecting the wide scholarly respect Mumtaz Ali commanded across intellectual circles.

 

Deputy Nazir Ahmad (1831–1912)

Deputy Nazir Ahmad was one of the earliest Urdu novelists of colonial India and a prominent social reformer associated with the Aligarh intellectual environment. Rather than establishing institutions, he chose fiction as a tool of reform, using storytelling to reshape attitudes toward women’s education and moral development. Nazir Ahmad was a brave academic to write about women’s education in his time, highlighting the sanctity and respect of women, but not their individual identity. Deputy Nazir Ahmad expressed dissatisfaction with traditional education and the poor state of women’s education during the post-revolutionary era. He argued that to overcome political and social decline, the nation should focus on improving educational awareness and social deterioration. Some thinkers supported education, while others opposed it. Nazir Ahmed believed that educated and conscious women would guide future generations better, besides handling household affairs. He aimed to ensure that women were educated and conscious to guide their future generations.

His first novel, Mirat-ul-Uroos, was written to address backwardness in women’s education. The book combines the virtues of educated women with the disadvantages of a lack of education through a fictional story, comparing literate and illiterate women. This novel serves as a powerful tool for educating girls and promoting gender equality.

 

Khwaja Altaf Hussain Hali (1837-1914)

Khwaja Altaf Hussain Hali was a major Urdu poet, critic, and social reformer associated with the reformist spirit of the 19th century. He believed that poetry should serve a social purpose by addressing real social problems rather than focusing only on romantic themes. Influenced by the reformist ideas of his time, Hali emphasised moral improvement, education, and especially the condition of women. His poetry is realistic, purposeful, and closely connected to society. In Chup Ki Daad and Munajat-e-Bewa, Hali presents women’s suffering within a patriarchal system. In Chup Ki Daad (Praise of Silence), female silence is shown as a quality admired by society, where women are expected to endure pain quietly and are praised for patience and obedience. However, from a feminist perspective, this silence reflects suppression, as women’s identities are shaped by self-sacrifice rather than self-expression. Similarly, in Munajat-e-Bewa (The Widow’s Prayer), Hali gives voice to a widow who expresses her sorrow and helplessness before God, highlighting her emotional and economic vulnerability. Through these portrayals, Hali questions rigid gender roles that keep women dependent and marginalised, while expressing deep sympathy for their condition. In 1878, Altaf Hussain Hali produced Majalis-un-Nisa, a didactic work that played a significant role in promoting the importance of women’s education and moral refinement in Indian society. Written in the form of instructive conversations, the work sought to educate women about ethical conduct, household management, religious understanding, and intellectual awareness. Hali, closely associated with the Aligarh reform movement, viewed women’s education as essential for the moral and social regeneration of the community. Through accessible language and practical guidance, Majalis-un-Nisa helped normalise the idea that educated women were vital not only for stable families but also for the broader progress of society. The text became part of a wider reformist effort that used literature as a means to gradually reshape social attitudes toward women’s learning in late 19th-century India.

 

Syed Ameer Ali (1849–1928)

Syed Ameer Ali,a renowned Muslim intellectual and activist, holds a significant place in Indian history as an instrumental figure in advocating for the socio-political rights of Muslims. His contributions encompassed various spheres, including education, politics, and the legal arena. He was a pioneering Indian-British jurist, scholar, and politician who advocated for improving the status of women. He authored influential works like The Spirit of Islam (1891) and The Legal Position of Women in Islam (1912), promoting education, opposing polygamy, and arguing for women’s rights.

 

Mullah Tyab Ali Bhai Mian (1844–1906)

Mullah Tyab Ali Bhai Mian, popularly known as Badruddin Tyabji, is known for his passion for education and contributions made to national causes through the Indian National Congress as its first President from a minority community. Tyabji’s own education and upbringing, which was a harmonic blend of East and West, made him acutely aware of the lack of it, especially among Muslims. Badruddin Tyabji, Pherozeshah Mehta, and Kashinath Telang were popularly known as ‘The Triumvirate’ or ‘The Three Stars’ of Bombay’s public life.

Tyabji emphasised women’s education, social equality, and modernisation. As the first Muslim Chief Justice of the Bombay High Court, Badruddin Tyabji made significant contributions to the Indian legal system, upholding principles of justice, constitutionalism, and equality before the law. His commitment extended beyond the courtroom to broader social reform, particularly in women’s rights, education, and communal harmony. Through his progressive outlook, Tyabji sought to harmonise tradition with modern legal and social values, setting an important precedent for future reformers.

His reformist vision emphasised educational advancement, social equality, and the reinterpretation of customary practices in light of contemporary realities. He advocated for women’s education and participation in public life. By encouraging critical engagement with inherited traditions, Tyabji fostered progressive thinking within the Muslim community and contributed meaningfully to India’s wider socio-cultural transformation.

 

Zakir Husain Khan (1897-1969)

Zakir Husain Khan was an Indian educationist and politician who served as the Vice President of India from 1962 to 1967 and President of India from 1967 until he died in 1969. Although Zakir Husain is not usually described as a women-specific reformer like Sayyid Mumtaz Ali, his contribution to Indian women was deep, structural, and long-lasting. He worked through education, institutional reform, and national policy, which gradually expanded opportunities for women across India.

 

Maulana Ashraf Ali Thanwi (1863-1943)

Maulana Ashraf Ali Thanwi, often referred to as Hakimul Ummat and Mujaddidul Millat, was an Indian Muslim scholar, jurist, thinker, theologian, reformist, and revivalist of classical Sufism in the Indian subcontinent during the British Raj. He was deeply shaped by the intellectual concerns of his time, particularly the growing recognition of women’s vital role in both personal moral development and the ethical strengthening of society. A cornerstone of his influence lies in BihishtiZewar (Heavenly Ornaments), composed in the early 20th century as a comprehensive guide for women. The work sought to make knowledge accessible within the domestic sphere, offering practical guidance on daily conduct, family life, personal growth, and social responsibility. By presenting everyday responsibilities as meaningful practices connected to moral consciousness, Thanwi contributed to expanding literacy among women and encouraged their active participation in shaping ethically grounded households and communities. Widely read and taught in homes and educational settings across South Asia, the text played a significant role in fostering a culture of learning among women and helped integrate moral education with everyday life, leaving an enduring influence on patterns of female education and social refinement in the region.

 

Vakkom Mohammed Abdul Khader Moulavi (1873-1932)

Vakkom Mohammed Abdul Khader Moulavi, popularly known as VakkomMoulavi, was a social reformer, teacher, prolific writer, Muslim scholar, journalist, freedom fighter, and newspaper proprietor in Travancore, a former princely state in southern India that was part of the present-day Kerala State. Moulavi is considered one of the greatest reformers in the Kerala Muslim community and is widely considered the Father of Muslim Renaissance in Kerala. He emphasised the religious and socioeconomic aspects much more than the ritualistic aspects of religion. He also campaigned for the need for modern education, the education of women, and the elimination of potentially bad customs among the Muslim community.

 

Saiyid Hamid (1920-2014): Torchbearer of Education

Another significant figure in the landscape of educational reform was Saiyid Hamid, whose contributions cannot be overlooked while discussing women’s development. A firm believer in education as a powerful instrument of social transformation, he consistently encouraged Muslim youth to pursue higher studies and participate actively in national progress. His commitment to preparing young Muslims for civil services inspired the establishment of institutions such as Hamdard Public School and Jamia Hamdard, and he played a pivotal role in securing deemed university status for Jamia Hamdard from the UGC.

He is also remembered for launching an educational caravan in 1992 that travelled across the country, spreading the message of literacy, education, hygiene, health awareness, social reform, and communal harmony for over a decade.

After retirement, Hamid devoted himself entirely to the educational uplift of the community. He remained deeply concerned about the socio-educational backwardness of marginalised groups and was particularly troubled by high dropout rates among Muslim boys and the widespread deprivation of school education among Muslim girls, many of whom were confined to domestic spaces. He firmly believed that genuine community progress was impossible without the modern education of girls.

Influenced by the farsighted vision of Abdul Hameed, he joined hands in strengthening the Hamdard Education Society and further consolidating the foundations of Jamia Hamdard. He consistently advocated greater participation of Muslims in national civil administration, viewing representation and education as interconnected pillars of empowerment.

In every role, as a father, administrator, Vice-Chancellor of Aligarh Muslim University, educational reformer, and institution builder, Saiyid Hamid led by example and laid a path for others to carry forward his vision. His four-point awareness mission, eliminating illiteracy through universal and value-based education, promoting hygiene and health, encouraging social reform, and fostering communal harmony, remains a meaningful framework for honouring his enduring legacy.

 

Maulana Dr. Kalbe Sadiq (1939-2020)

Maulana Dr. Kalbe Sadiq was an Indian Islamic Shia scholar. He worked tirelessly for the unity between Shia and Sunni Muslims and also between Hindus and Muslims in India amid rising sectarianism and religious polarisation. He was awarded the coveted Padma Bhushan posthumously. He is also known for advocating the right of Muslim women to offer prayers in mosques, as is practised in several other countries. Women’s education likewise formed an integral part of his reformist agenda, reflecting his belief that social progress was inseparable from intellectual empowerment. Like a true scion of a progressive reformist tradition, he upheld the view that communities flourish when women are granted equal access to knowledge, dignity, and public participation. His efforts thus positioned him not merely as a legal authority but as a principled voice for balanced reform rooted in justice and social responsibility.

Last but not least, this discussion turns to A.P.J. Abdul Kalam, whose visionary leadership and commitment to education and scientific progress contributed significantly to shaping a new national identity grounded in knowledge, innovation, and inclusive development.

 

A.P.J. Abdul Kalam (1931–2015)

A.P.J. Abdul Kalam was an Indian scientist and politician who played a leading role in the development of India’s missile and nuclear weapons programmes. He was the President of India from 2002 to 2007. His scientific achievements and popularity gained him the epithets “Missile Man” and “People’s President.”

Unlike earlier reformers who addressed women’s uplift primarily through social or educational debate, A. P. J. Abdul Kalam approached empowerment through a developmental vision, believing that when education, technology, and opportunity reach society’s margins, women naturally emerge as equal participants in national progress.

Alongside his immense contributions to science and technology, Abdul Kalam advanced a visionary developmental framework through his PURA (Providing Urban Amenities in Rural Areas) model, which sought to bridge the divide between rural and urban India by ensuring access to education, infrastructure, employment opportunities, and technological resources. His vision extended beyond scientific achievement to the holistic empowerment of society, emphasising inclusive growth and equal opportunity for all citizens, including women. By advocating education, self-reliance, and social participation, Kalam redefined national progress as a collective moral and intellectual journey. His legacy thus stands not only in laboratories and institutions, but also in the aspirations he ignited among ordinary Indians, making him a transformative figure in modern India’s social and developmental discourse.

The story of India’s transformation cannot be told without acknowledging the vital role played by Muslim intellectuals in reshaping women’s roles in education, patronage, and community life. Through perseverance, reformist thought, and institution-building, they challenged stagnation and opened pathways to knowledge and public participation for women. Their contributions demonstrate that social progress emerges not from isolation, but from collective responsibility and inclusive vision. In recognising Indian Muslims’ contribution toward changing women’s roles, we also recognise a broader commitment to national development, one in which empowered women stand at the heart of a stronger and more enlightened India.