Political Discourse in 21st-Century India Sinks to Its Lowest Ebb

The Modi era witnessed a sharp decline in the standards of political debates, and this began soon after Modi assumed the office of Chief Minister of Gujarat. The derision of political rivals now seems to have become the most prominent feature of his political personality. Mocking rivals has now become a part of his habit,…

Written by

Syed Khalique Ahmed

Published on

Political discourse in India seems to have fallen to its lowest ebb over the last two decades, especially with Narendra Modi’s rise, first as Chief Minister of Gujarat and then as Prime Minister. However, it would be wrong to place the entire blame on the declining standard of political debate on Modi alone. The Opposition parties are also to blame for their share in the falling standard of political communication and for mocking their rivals. The debate on the issue started after Modi described Rahul Gandhi as a ‘failed product’ and Congress as a ‘parasite’ at the NDTV World Summit 2026 on Oct. 22, 2026, in the national capital. This was followed by Congress party’s national president Mallikarjun Kharge remarking that ‘Modi ka baap bhi jayega’, allegedly dragging the deceased father of Modi into the political dispute, while addressing his party’s programme on Oct. 25, 2026, in Patna.

There was a time when India’s first Prime Minister Pt. Jawaharlal Nehru accommodated even his staunchest critics and political rivals in his cabinet, like Dr Shyama Prasad Mookerjee as Minister of Industry and Supply. Pt. Nehru also accommodated the Congress party’s fierce critic, Dr B.R. Ambedkar, by appointing him India’s first Law Minister and head of the team assigned to draft the Constitution. Pt. Nehru and his successors, including Lal Bahadur Shastri and even Indira Gandhi, never used labels to ridicule their political opponents either within the party or outside. They always maintained decorum and decency while addressing their rivals with names or without names, whether inside Parliament or in public or private programmes outside. The same was the situation during the terms of subsequent PMs like Chaudhary Charan Singh, Rajiv Gandhi, V.P. Singh, Chandrashekhar, P.V. Narasimha Rao and A.B. Vajpayee.

Maintaining Parliamentary Decorum

Nehru accommodated his political rivals not because he felt intimidated by them. He was such a tall personality that nobody could match his status, neither in the ruling party nor the opposition. But Nehru recognised that democracy required political disagreement and a strong opposition. His approach helped establish parliamentary conventions during the formative years of the Indian Republic. Vajpayee also respected democratic opposition. He never attacked his opponents. Through his public image and political practice, he placed greater emphasis on parliamentary argument, rhetoric, and coalition-building.

Indira Gandhi was considered to be a very tough leader, but she never insulted Opposition leaders by using derogatory labels against them. V.P. Singh’s government fell after BJP withdrew support to it but Singh maintained parliamentary decency. He did not call names to BJP leaders.

Rajiv Gandhi and P.V. Narasimha Rao, too, faced intense criticism from Opposition leaders on issues of corruption: Rajiv in the Bofors gun purchase case and Narasimha Rao in the 1993 JMM bribery case to survive the no-confidence motion against his government in the Lok Sabha. But both of them maintained a high level of parliamentary decency towards his critics in the Opposition.

The lessons drawn from the conduct of these great leaders are that Opposition parties are not enemies of the state or the government. They are an essential part of democracy.

The democratic credentials of a prime minister do not depend just on winning elections but also on whether opponents can criticise the government, participate in Parliamentary discussions and seek to replace the government through free and fair elections.

Derision of Political Rivals

Against this, the Modi era witnessed personalised political communication, using nicknames and slogans to attack rival party leaders during electoral campaigns and even after that, just to keep his and his party’s constituents in good humour. So, the Modi era witnessed a sharp decline in the standards of political debates, and this began soon after Modi assumed the office of Chief Minister of Gujarat. The derision of political rivals now seems to have become the most prominent feature of his political personality. Mocking rivals has now become a part of his habit, and BJP workers and supporters are imitating it.

Modi used derogatory language not for individuals alone in rival political parties but for entire communities whom he considered politically aligned to other parties. In his speeches during Gaurav Yatra, taken out by him after the 2002 anti-Muslim riots throughout Gujarat, Modi used the slogan ‘Hum Panch, Hamare Pachees’ (We are five, we will beget 25). He used this slogan to deride Muslim families by insinuating that a Muslim man with four wives could have 25 children and that Congress was pampering this.

In the same rallies, he also described Muslims as ‘puncture-walas’ (one who repairs tyres and tubes). As a puncture-fixing job is low-skilled and poorly paid, Modi insulted Muslims by projecting them as socially and occupationally inferior.

Modi also used terms such as urban Naxal and mental Naxal in his Independence Day speech on Aug. 15 this year to discredit intellectuals, activists, academics, journalists, and political opponents who are engaged in peaceful dissent rather than armed insurgency. By presenting ideological dissent as an issue of threat to national security, Modi portrayed the legitimate political disagreement as a threat to the nation.

Stating that “the armed Naxals are gone, but mental Naxals (Dimagi Naxals) are trying various tactics to drag society onto the wrong path,” Modi made a provocative suggestion that such people needed to be identified and isolated.

In his election speeches in 2002, Modi publicly mocked then-Chief Election Commissioner J.M. Lyngdoh by repeatedly calling him out by his full name – James Michael Lyngdoh – to draw attention to his religion and provoke sentiments of the majority community against constitutional bodies.

He frequently attacked Congress leadership by referring to Congress President Sonia Gandhi with labels like ‘dus numbari’, a term associated with police records for habitual criminals and notorious offenders. Modi referred to her so because of her New Delhi address at 10 Janpath. Such language had never been used by any political leader for his rivals in the past.

Exchange of Contemptuous Phrases

The Congress then retaliated with Sonia Gandhi calling Modi ‘Maut ka Saudagar’ (Merchant of Death), referring to more than 1200 people, mostly Muslims, killed in the 2002 Gujarat riots and holding Modi responsible for it.

This exchange of contemptuous phrases for each other by two major political leaders degenerated into no-holds-barred personal attacks, ridicule, and political mudslinging. An article titled “Twitter and the Projection of Political Personalities in India”, by Vihang Jumle and Vignesh Karthik KR, published in Commonwealth & Comparative Politics in 2024, analysing Modi’s political communication, concludes that Modi politically benefited by using labels against Rahul Gandhi rather than criticising Congress’ policies. The authors, who analysed the political Twitter trends about Modi, say that the use of political ridicule to influence voters and destroy images of rivals in the public mind brought down the quality of democratic debate.

Modi and Amit Shah used the nickname ‘Pappu’ to insult Rahul Gandhi during the run-up to elections in 2014 and 2019. While the word ‘Pappu’ is affectionately used for a young boy to show love, it is also used to ridicule somebody, suggesting that he is immature, unintelligent, inexperienced, and incapable. BJP leaders used the word ‘Pappu’ for Rahul Gandhi, suggesting that he is politically incompetent, immature, and incapable of leading his party and becoming Prime Minister of the country.

Modi also repeatedly addressed Rahul as ‘Shehzada’, used for the political heir to a king but is also interpreted as childish in political parlance, meaning that Rahul Gandhi was not capable of becoming Prime Minister.

Rahul Gandhi was also called ‘Namuna’, literally meaning specimen or example. When Narendra Modi used it for Rahul Gandhi during the 2014 general election campaign, it was intended as a derogatory or mocking reference, suggesting that Rahul Gandhi was an odd or ridiculous character.

Modi also compared Rahul with comedian Kapil Sharma, suggesting that Rahul Gandhi was not a serious politician and was in politics just to entertain and pass the time, thus bringing down his image in the eyes of his supporters and the general public.

In July 2024, Modi repeatedly used the expression ‘Balak Buddhi’ (childish mind, immature thinking) to mock Rahul Gandhi’s conduct and speech in Parliament. Modi also mocked Rahul Gandhi by describing his hug in Parliament as ‘bachkani harkat’ (childish antics).

Modi used the phrase ‘Jersey cow’ to mock Sonia Gandhi’s Italian origins and question her identity in Indian politics. He also described Rahul Gandhi as ‘Jersey calf’, suggesting that his political identity was derived from his mother’s foreign origins and that he had no pure Indian roots.

Modi did not even spare former Prime Minister Manmohan Singh, who brought revolutionary changes in the Indian economy by allowing foreign direct investment as finance minister. Modi mocked him by calling him ‘Maun Mohan Singh’, suggesting that Singh was silent on rising prices, poverty and corruption allegations. This also meant that he was a weak prime minister and failed to assert his authority. It became a recurring feature of the BJP’s criticism of Manmohan Singh in the run-up to the 2014 general election.

Attacking Rahul Gandhi at an election rally on May 9, 2024, in Lakhimpur Kheri in Uttar Pradesh, over the issue of the Citizenship Amendment Act, Union Home Minister Amit Shah said, “Are Rahul Baba! Aap to kya, aapki Nani bhi upar se wapas aa jaaye, to is CAA ko nahi hata paayegi.” (Hey, Rahul Baba! Forget about you – even if your maternal grandmother were to return from heaven, she wouldn’t be able to repeal the CAA.). The reference was provocative and personal rather than simply a criticism of the Congress party. This indicates how far our politicians have gone to prove themselves stronger and superior to their rivals.

Kharge, addressing a programme of his party in Patna on Oct. 25, said that the Congress, when it comes to power, would send all those involved in committing irregularities in the SIR of electoral rolls to jail. Interrupting Kharge, a youth named Santosh Kumar said: “Modi nahin jayega” (Modi would not go). In response, Kharge lost his balance and retorted, “Modi ka baap bhi jayega,” meaning that even Modi’s father would not be spared.

Kharge’s remarks have been interpreted differently by BJP and Congress leaders. While the BJP condemned them as ‘indecent’ and ‘abusive’, arguing that they were directed at the Prime Minister’s deceased father, the Congress maintained that Kharge’s comments were aimed at the RSS, which it regards as the ideological parent of the BJP. All hell broke loose after this, and all senior BJP leaders from Amit Shah to Rajnath Singh and BJP national President Nitin Nabin verbally attacked Kharge and accused him of violating all norms of decorum.  They said it reflected the Congress party’s ‘ideological bankruptcy’.