Film: Saffron War: A War against Nation
by Rajiv Yadav, Shahanawaz Alam and Lakshman Prashad
Duration: 61 Minutes
Contribution: Rs 95
Available from: 632/13, Shankarpuri, Kamta, Post: Chinhat, Lucknow, UP
Reviewed by RAM PUNIYANI
With the rise of Hindutva movement during the last three decades there has also been an attempt to understand this phenomenon through analytic essays, articles and films. These films have also served the purpose of spreading the awareness about the rising threat of communal politics, and dangers to national integration due to the rising communal tide in the society.
The Mumbai violence, Gujarat genocide, Kandhamal, among others has been the object of serious study and analysis among the activists and scholars. ‘Saffron War: A War against nation’ is the latest in the series of the significant works, which have come out lately. This film is a unique combination of analysis of Hindutva ideology, its cooption of Dalits into communal politics and the gradual manipulation of the low caste movements from their struggle for social justice to their current mobilisation in the fold of Hindutva where they are made to believe that the real problems of society are not due to the caste structure but the external one coming from Muslim minorities.
This film is made in the backdrop of Gorakhpur, where Yogi Adiyanath, a BJP MP has been spreading his tentacles in a very aggressive way. The film’s major contribution is to show as to how Gorakhnath Math has been gradually kept from its struggle against caste oppression, how its focus on intercommunity amity has been shifted to hatred for the minorities.
The film, through different interviews and visuals, shows us the spread of venom against minorities. The language used by the Yogi and his followers comes under the category of ‘Hate Speech’, which is going on in the open fashion. All the prejudices and biases against minorities, Muslims in particular, are being openly asserted in the public meetings where not only are the Muslims presented in the negative light but also violence is openly propagated and promoted. The imaginary fear of minorities is projected and all the propagation of violence is done in the name of ‘Defence of Hindu religion’.
The degree of aggression in the language is shocking, to say the least. In many meetings when these hateful speeches are made, even the police stand as the passive listeners, unmindful of the fact that such hate speech should invite strong legal action.
The major mobilisation is done in the name of Yogi Adityanath and the majority of people who are mobilised and co-opted are Dalits and OBCs. They begin with Savarkar’s definition of Hindutva and Hindu Rashtra is made the base of hate-others-propaganda. This goes on to say that Muslims have to be relegated to second class citizenship. They cite the example of Pakistan to spread this hate.
Yogi’s propaganda further adds that Muslims’ voting rights have to be taken away. Gorakhpur and surrounding areas must be one of the few places where Savarkar is quoted so blatantly in the anti-minority tirade. The emphasis on converting UP into Gujarat through Uttaranchal comes up regularly. On the lines of Bajrang Dal, there is formation of Arya Veer Sena and Hindu Yuva Vahini, giving training to youth in the use of arms, with Har Har Mahadev as the war cry.
The film brings out clearly as to how the earlier Bharat Milap procession in this area symbolised Hindu-Muslim brotherhood, but now it has been converted into the occasion where anti-Muslim sentiments are invoked. This has seriously intimidated the minorities in the area. The role of these forces in the Mau riots of 2005 is well brought out in this film.
While the film does well to focus on the core points of Savarkar ideology and cooption, Sanskritisation of Dalits, there is a need to link up this with the overall Hindutva politics of the country. The link between Savarkar and the RSS ideology also should have been highlighted. The strong point of the film is to show the political dynamics of conversion of a low caste, syncretic space into the one dominated by Brahminical ideology and Hindutva politics.
The film does show, in a forthright manner, the way in which the Hindutva politics builds up. The history of Gorakhnath Math comes out very well along with the fact the communalisation process has converted these syncretic spaces into exclusive Hindutva places. It is Gorakhnath Math where Muslims used to throng in large numbers and were welcome there. The scenario is dismal, there is need to develop political, ideological and cultural campaigns against this politics to bring back the issues of caste and gender in the mainstream of social movements. Work for national integration needs to be highlighted in more ways than one.
While the film is a comprehensive study of communalism in Uttaranchal, Gorakhpur in particular, it should have connected a bit more with the national phenomenon. The film does need some technical improvisation.