MOHAMMAD NAUSHAD KHAN argues that besides equipping judiciary amply with advanced technology and better infrastructure, it is also equally important to impart sensitivity towards social justice in order to make justice delivery system more effective and more trustworthy.
The issues of judicial reform, speedy trial, justice delivery system, backlog of pending cases and overburdened judiciary have been debated many a time in the past and continue to occupy space in the media till date. Infrastructure, number of judges in courts including fast track ones and budgetary support will no doubt help justice delivery institutions expedite judicial process but the delivery of justice will fairly depend on the level of sensitivity towards social justice.
In cases of Babri Masjid demolition, innocents languishing in jail, thousands of riot cases, fake encounters, and others like Bhopal gas tragedy and Bhanwari Devi gang rape cases, it is the mindset and lack of sensitivity that have come in way, as many believe, towards justice delivery and not only the nitty-gritty of judicial process and lack of infrastructural development. But at the same time, within the limited given infrastructure, justice has been done in a plenty of cases like those of Jesica Lal murder and many innocent Muslims, who were held on trumped-up terror charges but later acquitted by the courts of law. The role of the Supreme Court in 2G spectrum cases and black money in particular in recent time has been exemplary and few more such cases will surely help to revive and restore the faith of people in judiciary, and judicial process and the delivery of justice.
Ravi Nair, Director South Asia Human Rights Documentation Centre, told Radiance that Special Courts are a palliative not the solution. As of 6 April 2013, there were over 3 crore cases pending in various courts in the country. Of these 26 per cent were over five years old. Early disposal of these cases without sacrificing due process of law is paramount to the administration of justice. The government has been talking about doubling the existing number of District and Subordinate Courts. There will be a need to provide the requisite staff and infrastructure for these courts. Filling vacancies in the High Courts and subordinate courts should be a priority. India has only about 15 judges to a million of population. This is a ridiculously low figure.
“In the ninth plan, judiciary received 0.071 per cent of the plan allocation. In the tenth plan, the allocation was 0.078 per cent. This is niggardly. Successive governments have not implemented the recommendations of the Law Commission and the recommendations of the Committee on Judicial arrears. There is wilful neglect of the right of citizens to prompt access to justice,” said Nair.
Bihar has got the highest number of fast track courts in the country with 179 of them functional till date. This is followed by Maharashtra, Madhya Pradesh, UP, West Bengal, Andhra Pradesh and Gujarat. The Centre has also planned to set up 1,800 fast track courts (FTCs) to expedite justice delivery system. The government has also proposed setting up 460 family courts in the next five years in districts with a population of one million or more.
The budget for 2015-16 has allocated Rs. 806.2 crore for the development of judicial infrastructure in states and union territories, the National Mission for Justice Delivery and legal Reforms. But, surprisingly, the allocation for computerisation has been scaled down to Rs 29.87 crore as against Rs 58 crore allocated during 2014-15. The grant allocated for the states for the development of judicial infrastructure has been earmarked in 2015-16 at Rs. 443.69 crore which is roughly half of Rs.842.40 crore allocated in the revised budget estimates last year. Budgetary allocation for the Union territory has been earmarked at Rs 63 crore as against Rs 60 crore allocated last year. The Supreme Court has been allocated Rs. 562.99 crore for plan expenditure which is Rs. 373.01 crore less than what was allocated under the plan head in the last budget.
A 3-day, regional judicial conference on the issue of ‘strengthening justice delivery system: tools and techniques’ was held in Bengaluru on 27 February to facilitate sharing of knowledge, views and experience among the judges from the neighbouring states. In the conference, several topics like transforming justice delivery system and criminal justice system were discussed. As per recent statistics available with the Law Ministry, there are 349 vacancies of judges in 24 high courts and three in the Supreme Court. Presently, the ratio of judges to population is 10.5 to one million. It is the lowest as compared to other developed countries. For example, Europe has more than 150 judges per million and the US has nearly 100 judges per million.
Senior Supreme Court judge, Justice Thakur, who is believed to be the next Chief Justice of India, while delivering a lecture at Asia-Pacific International Summit on Mediation in New Delhi on 13 February, said that “lack of governance” and “officials’ inability to take decisions” are prime reasons behind the deluge of cases choking the justice delivery system.
Justice J S Khehar, while speaking on the occasion, emphasised on the necessity of creating an atmosphere as well as adequate infrastructure to resolve dispute timely and effectively.
Lok Sabha speaker Sumitra Mahajan, while addressing the sixth convocation ceremony of Gujarat National Law University (GNLU), said it’s saddening that 63,800 cases are pending in the Supreme Court and 4.4 million in high courts and 20 million in district courts across the country. Mahajan also said that more than 2.5 crore cases are pending in courts across India and this sorry state is due to lack of efficient lawyers, judges and courts.
The Supreme Court’s Rs 2,700 crore e-courts proposed project to expedite justice delivery system has been gathering dust for the last 14 months with the government. Chief justice of Orissa High Court Amitav Roy, while speaking at the inaugural session of national seminar on ‘Enhancing judicial capability’ held in Cuttack in February, stressed on the need to use modern technology for expediting justice delivery. Roy said presently judicial system is primarily dependent on combination of manual processes and ageing computers.
Now, besides equipping judiciary amply with advanced technology and better infrastructure, it is also equally important to impart sensitivity towards social justice in order to make justice delivery system more effective and more trustworthy. Judiciary can, on many occasions, guide the leaders and the government towards social welfare and development without encroaching upon the rights of the people as well as the executive. Judiciary is capable enough to turn the pace of the country towards development and growth or even compel the leaders and the government to follow the path of development rather than the issues that can prove impediment to the growth and development.


