The Midterm Verdict from America

Trump, Netanyahu and their cronies should understand that oppression and perpetrating evil has its limits. There will come a time when their power will evaporate and they will have to face the consequences of their crimes and wrongdoings. The arc of the moral universe is long, but it bends toward justice.

Written by

Arshad Shaikh

Published on

The results of the US midterm elections delivered a powerful jolt to Donald Trump and the Republican Party. Democrats captured both chambers of Congress, translating to a huge setback for the ruling party. The midterm debacle shows complete public dissatisfaction with Trump’s domestic policies, his confrontational style of governance, and his approach to war and his relationship with Israel.

The Domestic Backlash against Trump

Even political pundits were surprised at the scale of the Republican setback.  The Republicans lost traditional strongholds such as Kansas and Texas. Kansas had not elected a Democratic leader since 1932, while Texas had remained a Republican bastion since 1988. It was clear that the discontent went far beyond the usual swing constituencies.

A major driver for this antigovernmental anger was the worsening cost of living. Trump had promised during his 2024 campaign to make everyday life more affordable. Instead, Americans faced rising food and fuel prices. The unending war with Iran led to higher petrol and diesel costs. Unlike Europe, the US’s dependence on private transport makes fuel-price increases particularly harmful for ordinary households. Inflation crossed 3% to 3.5%. Trump faced the wrath of voters over healthcare too. The withdrawal of Obamacare subsidies affected small towns and rural communities. The closure of hospitals forced people to travel longer distances for treatment.

Immigration enforcement created a lot of ‘bad press’ and public unease. Videos and images of the Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) detaining immigrants in the most brutal and barbaric manner became a visible symbol of the administration’s high-handed approach. There was a growing perception that the President was more concerned with personal projects and displays of wealth than with public priorities.

Gaza and the Political Cost of Supporting Israel

However, the midterm verdict was not influenced by domestic economic concerns alone. Americans began to question the wars in Gaza and Iran, and the wider question of America’s relationship with Israel. Public outrage over the devastation in Gaza seriously damaged the image of the administration and the ruling party. American voters slowly realised how their taxes were financing the Gaza genocide and the futile war with Iran.

The political consequences were particularly visible in Michigan. Democrat Abdulrahman Muhammad Al-Sayyiddefeated Republican Mike Rogers in a closely watched Senate contest. A staunch pro-Palestine and a proud Muslim, Al-Sayed faced an extensive campaign against him by the American Israel Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC) and its affiliates. AIPAC and associated organisations spent nearly $30 million attempting to defeat him in the Democratic primary.

An election-night poll found that 62% of voters considered the joint US-Israeli initiation of the Iran war wrong, while 74% identified it as a major or crucial factor in their voting decisions. In 2024, Trump had promised voters to oppose ‘forever wars’ and to end the violence in Gaza. The President had broken his promise. Vice President JD Vance identified four reasons for the Republican drubbing.  The Iran war, rising living costs, putting America First, and changing the US relationship with Israel.

What Happens to Trump Now?

The Democrats’ control of Congress will bring Trump’s administration under much greater scrutiny. There would be greater scrutiny of the people around the President. Alleged corruption charges, business dealings, and possible misuse of executive power would be investigated.

Experts predict that the Democrats may try to impeach Trump just before the next Presidential elections in 2028. Till then, however, he would continue to enjoy the powers of the presidency, including the ability to veto legislation passed by Congress. An extended confrontation between the White House and the Democratic-controlled legislature is on the cards for the near foreseeable future.

A Changing America

The results point to some unprecedented changes in the behaviour of the American electorate. There were significant shifts towards the Democrats among different voter groups. For example, 17% of male voters, 13% of white voters, 28% of Hispanic voters and 32% of younger voters moved towards the Democrats compared with the previous electoral pattern.

The election of candidates from immigrant and minority backgrounds showed America’s changing social composition. AbdulrahmanAl-Sayed’s victory in Michigan, along with the success of Indian-origin candidates such as Pramila Jayapal and Rohit Khanna, marked a new era for the Arab and Asian American communities.

Implications for India

Democratic control of Congress could complicate the approval of a proposed India-US trade agreement. Politically influential Indian businessmen may receive renewed Congressional scrutiny of their business arrangements in the USA.

There could be renewed discussion in Washington about press freedom, human rights, and freedom of expression in India. Indian-origin lawmakers who have criticised the Indian government’s policies may gain greater media visibility.

The broader international implications are equally important. If Trump manages to have a trade agreement with China, it could have serious consequences for India. America’s relationship with Pakistan would also be closely watched by New Delhi.

The Moral Dimension

Apart from the technical analysis of the midterm polls, one cannot deny the moral dimension of such momentous events. Allah says in Surah Baqarah, “And were it not that Allah repelled some people with another, the earth would surely be overlaid with mischief.” (The Qur’an 2:251) The verse enunciates the principle that God treats the nations and those whom He bestowed power as part of His Divine system governing the world. He allows various nations to attain power and strength within certain limits. But when any nation or a powerful group begins to commit wrongs and exceed reasonable limits, God brings forth another nation and group as a counterweight. Were the dominion of one nation or party to endure for ever and were its capacity to perpetrate wrongs granted in perpetuity, God’s earth would become full of corruption and wickedness.

Trump, Netanyahu and their cronies should understand that oppression and perpetrating evil has its limits. There will come a time when their power will evaporate and they will have to face the consequences of their crimes and wrongdoings. The arc of the moral universe is long, but it bends toward justice.