Visa Row at Bharat Summit Puts India’s Press Freedom and Democratic Credentials Under Scrutiny

The contrast between Norway’s high position in global press freedom rankings and India’s much lower ranking has already become part of the debate following Lyng’s earlier encounter with Modi. Her last-minute exclusion has given that debate a fresh international dimension.

Written by

Abdul Bari Masoud

Published on

The revocation of the Indian visa granted to Norwegian journalist HelleLyng Svendsen, barely ten minutes before she was scheduled to leave for the airport in Oslo, and the reported denial of entry to more than 100 foreign speakers invited to the Congress Party’s Bharat Summit in Hyderabad have once again brought India’s record on press freedom, freedom of expression and democratic openness into sharp focus.

The controversy has raised uncomfortable questions about the functioning of the country’s democratic institutions, the exercise of executive power and the government’s willingness to accommodate critical voices from abroad. It has also triggered a debate over the apparent contradiction between India’s claim to be the world’s largest democracy and its treatment of journalists, academics, political representatives and civil society figures who seek to participate in international discussions on democracy and governance.

The controversy erupted after it emerged that approx. 113 of the 315 foreign speakers initially cleared by the Ministry of External Affairs (MEA) to participate in the Bharat Summit had reportedly been denied entry into India or had their visas cancelled at the last minute. Congress MP Shashi Tharoor subsequently put the number at 115.

The two-day summit, held in Hyderabad on Nov. 13 and 14, brought together international political leaders, policymakers, academics, representatives of civil society and other prominent figures from around 70 countries. The event was intended to provide a platform for discussions on the changing global order, democracy, social and economic justice, climate change, gender equality, international relations and the future of cooperation between the Global North and Global South.

However, the reported visa cancellations cast a shadow over the gathering even before it began. According to sources close to the organisers, around 202 delegates managed to reach India, while a substantial number of those who had been invited and reportedly received the necessary clearances couldn’t attend.

Among those affected was Norwegian journalist HelleLyng, whose case has become particularly controversial because of her previous public encounter with Prime Minister Narendra Modi during his visit to Norway in May.

A Journalist’s Uncomfortable Questions

Lyng had attracted considerable attention in India and internationally when she questioned Modi during his visit to Norway, asking whether he would take questions from the country’s press.At a media interaction with the Norwegian Prime Minister and Modi, both leaders initially read out prepared statements. When Lyng attempted to ask a question, the Indian Prime Minister did not respond.

She later wrote on social media: “Prime Minister of India, Narendra Modi, would not take my question, I was not expecting him to.”

She pointed out the contrast between Norway’s position at the top of the World Press Freedom Index and India’s ranking at 157th, writing that journalists had a responsibility to question the political leadership of countries with which their governments maintained relations. “It is our job to question the powers we cooperate with,” she said.

When both prime ministers ignored her question, Lyng reportedly pursued them towards the elevator, insisting that journalists had been invited and that the visiting Indian Prime Minister should answer questions from the press.

The episode caused embarrassment for the Indian diplomatic establishment. The Indian Embassy subsequently invited Norwegian journalists to an interaction that evening, ostensibly to answer their questions. However, the meeting reportedly became controversial when a senior official of the MEA lectured the Norwegian media on India’s history and heritage instead of directly addressing the questions raised.

Lyng continued to follow developments in India after the incident. She wrote about Indian political developments and remained critical of the government’s policies, including the relationship between political power and influential corporate groups such as those led by Gautam Adani and Mukesh Ambani.

Visa Revoked at the Eleventh Hour

According to Lyng, she had obtained the necessary political clearance and an Indian visa to attend and speak at the Bharat Summit in Hyderabad. She was therefore preparing to travel to India when she received the information that she would not be permitted to enter the country.

The abrupt decision prompted her to record a 3.21-minute video message addressed directly to Union Home Minister Amit Shah, whose ministry was reportedly responsible for the intervention.The video, posted on social media on Wednesday night, quickly went viral. It reportedly attracted around seven lakh views within seven hours and was reposted approx. 5,500 times on X alone. It was also shared across other social media platforms, generating widespread discussion.

Addressing the Home Minister, Lyng questioned the reasons behind the decision and appealed to him to reconsider the restriction.She also raised the possibility that her critical views on the Adani-Ambani relationship and her writings on Indian political developments had contributed to the decision. “The ball is in your court, Mr Shah,” she said, ending her message with an appeal for dialogue: “We can work it out. Let us make it work.”

Congress Questions the Government’s Intervention

The Congress strongly criticised the reported denial of entry to the foreign delegates, describing the development as an embarrassment for a country that frequently presents itself as a leading democratic power.At the summit, Congress MP and senior leader Shashi Tharoor expressed disappointment over the cancellation of visas and the refusal of entry to a substantial number of foreign participants.

In a post on X on November 13, Tharoor said:“A disappointing footnote to the Bharat Summit proceedings: when I got to Hyderabad, I learned that 115 of the 315 speakers whom the External Affairs Ministry had cleared for the event ended up being refused entry to India or having their visas cancelled, apparently on the instructions of the Ministry of Home Affairs.”

Questioning the legal basis of the action, he added that it was “completely unclear under what provision of law the government has taken such a drastic step”.

“What a shame that a proud democracy has become so insecure that it must stifle any voices it fears will be critical!” he remarked.

Tharoor said the gathering had brought together experts from around 70 countries to discuss the emerging global order, India’s strategic response, cooperative federalism and electoral integrity.He participated in discussions involving international thinktanks and delivered the keynote address at the opening dinner on the changing world order.

The summit attracted around 1,000 delegates, including international policymakers, progressive political leaders and senior Congress figures Rahul Gandhi and Mallikarjun Kharge.

MEA’s Response

The Ministry of External Affairs offered its first public response to the controversy during its regular media briefing on Nov. 13.In response to a question, MEA spokesperson Randhir Jaiswal maintained that visa decisions were a sovereign function of every country.“I would like to say, and all of you are aware, that visa matters are sovereign functions of any country or any government. So, that is what I have to say,” he stated.

However, the spokesperson did not explain why the foreign participants had initially been cleared by the MEA and issued visas, only for some of those permissions to be subsequently withdrawn.

The question is not simply about India’s ower to grant or refuse visas. It is why participants who had reportedly received the required clearances were prevented from travelling at the eleventh hour, without a publicly available explanation.

What Do the Visa Guidelines Say?

The organisers also questioned the reported visa cancellations, citing government guidelines governing conference visas for foreign nationals.According to a person familiar with the summit arrangements, the relevant guidelines require prior political clearance for foreign participants attending conferences involving sensitive subjects such as South Asia, national security and Kashmir.The source maintained that the organisers had ensured that the summit’s programme did not involve discussions falling within those specified categories.

These include applications from nationals of Afghanistan, China, Sudan and Pakistan, people of Pakistani origin and stateless persons. Additional scrutiny is prescribed for participants intending to visit restricted areas or locations affected by terrorism, militancy or extremism.The organisers argued that the withdrawal of visas from participants who had already received the necessary clearances was not adequately explained by these provisions.

At a curtain-raiser press conference, Congress leader and chairman of the party’s Foreign Affairs Department Salman Khurshid had also clarified that no delegates from neighbouring countries were attending the summit.This raised further questions about the grounds on which the restrictions had been imposed.

Neither the Ministry of Home Affairs nor the Ministry of External Affairs had, in the material available at the time, provided a detailed explanation of the individual cases or clarified the precise number of participants affected.

Rahul Gandhi’s Sharp Attack

The controversy also became a central political issue during the summit, with Leader of the Opposition in the Lok Sabha Rahul Gandhi launching a sharp attack on the government over the exclusion of foreign delegates and the state of Indian democracy.

Addressing the gathering, Gandhi apologised to international participants who were prevented from entering India.He said Indian democracy, given the country’s size and diversity, was not merely an internal matter but a global asset whose survival was important for democratic movements across the world.

Referring to the absence of foreign delegates, he said the incident offered them a glimpse of the political environment in India as the democratic institutions had been weakened and the democracy had been destroyed in 2024.He also questioned the credibility of electoral outcomes, arguing that the functioning of democratic institutions required greater scrutiny.

Referring to Maharashtra, Gandhi pointed to the contrast between the Opposition’s performance in the parliamentary elections and its subsequent defeat in the Assembly elections held just three months later.

The Corporate-Political Nexus

Gandhi also used the international platform to highlight what he described as the growing nexus between big business and political power in India. As for Gautam Adani, he argued that the businessman’s extraordinary rise had coincided with the BJP’s ascent to power.Adani had been ranked around 600th among the world’s richest people before the BJP came to power and had subsequently risen to become the second richest.

He further claimed that the BJP’s assets had increased 11-fold over the past decade. “When a few businessmen own the government, the people lose their voice,” he said, underlining the importance of political accountability and democratic institutions.

The Bharat Summit 2026 was conceived as an international platform to discuss emerging global challenges and explore a new framework for international cooperation. The proposed institution, to be called ‘Our World Institute’, would bring together individuals associated with progressive political parties and movements across the world to discuss the challenges posed by the changing global order.

Questions That Demand Answers

The visa controversy has brought back the larger debate over India’s approach to press freedom, freedom of expression and the participation of international voices in discussions about its democracy.The case of Lyng is particularly significant because it involves a journalist who had previously sought to question India’s Prime Minister in a country known for its strong press freedom traditions. Her subsequent exclusion from an international conference on democracy and press freedom has inevitably invited scrutiny.

The contrast between Norway’s high position in global press freedom rankings and India’s much lower ranking has already become part of the debate following Lyng’s earlier encounter with Modi. Her last-minute exclusion has given that debate a fresh international dimension.