Dr Waquar Anwar, Secretary Board of Islamic Publications and Financial Adviser to Jamaat-e-Islami Hind, shared his perspective on the practical implications of and feasibility in alternative economy in the context of Islamic teachings, at a programme organised by Forum for Discussion on Economic Issues (FGDEI), a joint forum of Sahulat and Radiance Viewsweekly in the national capital on 1 November.
Dr Anwar, in his presentation, said that in real market we have some documents paid to somebody and these documents are used for the creation of other documents without any economic activity. “Suppose that we have some purchase documents. All of us have bank accounts and we have some purchase documents. We have to float something and we would go to the market suppose for Rs. 20,000 and get discounted through a bank. The bank gives all of us say Rs. 18,000. The bank may use that Rs. 20,000 as asset for the creation of further liabilities in the market,” said Dr Anwar. The market depends on the speculation and the real market is not based on the real economic activity. It is based on either type of balloon or some psychological factors creating economic recession. The big question: why we need alternative economy and the answer he suggested is that because the contemporary economy is non-real and it has created a kind of bubble which can burst.
During the presentation, Dr Anwar also highlighted the inherent problems of contemporary economy like trade cycle based on psychological factors, institutional debt crisis, sovereign debt crisis, corporate economy taking over the nation states, easy credit on the basis of future income and economy without savings. He also emphasised the practical implications of alternative economy where there is no justification for interest, economic transactions must be based on authority, and resources must remain in use, economy should be equity based and excessive speculation should be checked and gaming to be done away with.
“The base of alternative economy has been summarised that native resources are not basically scarce; efficiency is not the only criterion for allocation of resources and their fruits and man is the object of economic activity and not its subject. The interest has been distasteful throughout the history. Religions forbade it. Islam remained steadfast while others compromised. Interest and usury may be two distinct things in English, but they are the same in economics,” he observed
Circulation of fund and economy based on equity was also discussed. The presentation was followed by discussion and participants expressed their views on the subject.


